The eyes never lie, especially when it comes to aging. As we get older, this delicate area, which is 10 times thinner than the rest of our skin, is one of the first parts of the body to develop fine lines and wrinkles and crepey skin. Needless to say, finding an under eye concealer for over 50 skin that hides the sins of our youth can be a difficult feat. High-quality products with nourishing ingredients are of the utmost importance. Luckily, we’ve rounded up a great selection of under-eye concealers that brighten, lift, and won’t crease or bunch.
What are the most important ingredients for an under eye concealer?
While aging is of course natural and inevitable, it’s nice to have products that can help reduce the tell-time signs of father time as they work to provide nutrition to your skin, and when it comes to concealer, antioxidants are a great good place to start. These prevent further aging caused by harmful UV rays with vitamins E, C, and A.
Additionally, moisturizing and firming ingredients, such as hyaluronic acid and peptides, are smart things to search for. Hyaluronic acid hydrates, which can take away puffiness, dryness, and fill in lines. It’s also particularly important for under-eye concealer, as a lack of hydration in this type of makeup can cause creasing and flaking. Talk about a power team for perfect skin! Peptides, meanwhile, are applied to your face to give your body a cue to make more collagen for tight skin elasticity.
Concealer vs Foundation for Under Eyes
The difference between under-eye concealer and foundation can be confusing. Both cover, blur, and color correct, but concealer is typically heavier. Its main job is to really camouflage those dark circles and imperfections, such as blemishes. Foundation, meanwhile, is more of an all-over product that works with concealer to even your skin tone and give you a picture-perfect complexion. Using concealer as foundation would look cakey and feel way too thick. Using foundation as concealer, on the other hand, would make it far more difficult to cover acne or under-eye problems, since its consistency is too thin.
What color of under-eye concealer is right for me?
You may be surprised to learn that in addition to skin-toned shades, pastel colors are often useful for under-eye concealer to combat everything from under-eye circles to hyperpigmentation. When it comes to using these rainbow shades, we’ve got a chart below to help you out.
Best Under Eye Concealer for Women Over 50
Now that you know everything there is to know about concealer, you’re ready to pick one up. Keep scrolling for Woman’s World’s picks for the best under-eye concealer for women over 50.
See more of our best product recommendations.
We write about products we think our readers will like. If you buy them, we get a small share of the revenue from the supplier.
Where to buy: $30, Nars
For complete coverage that isn’t heavy, turn to this NARS concealer for all your cover-up needs. It’s oil-free, but far from drying, and helps to blur imperfections while brightening under-eye circles.
Writes one Sephora reviewer: “I am literally blown away by this concealer. It is completely unique to anything I’ve ever tried. Works for under eyes, eyelids, and redness on face, hides pores. Looks flawless and somehow doesn’t crease on my very dry, 50-year-old under-eyes! Try it, you won’t be disappointed.”
Where to buy: $27, Tarte
For luminous under-eyes that look like they’ve never seen a wrinkle, turn to Tarte’s Shape Tape, a concealer that’s known for working sheer magic. This 3-in-1 product allows you to highlight, conceal, and shape your face in one fell swoop.
One over-60 beauty blogger raved about Shape Tape on her popular vlog, saying, “I always have such trouble with concealers smearing underneath here, especially mascaras… with this I’ve had no trouble whatsoever.”
She simply dabs one dot under each eye with the side of the applicator that isn’t slanted and blends. “It really covers up so well and it doesn’t crease on me… I’ve been very, very pleased with this concealer.”
Where to buy: $27, Sephora
Your makeup should make you shine as bright as you feel inside. This concealer from IT Cosmetics illuminates to make you look wide awake without going overboard on the shimmer. That’s because brightening formulas combat dark circles and reduce the appearance of under-eye bags to lighten up your face, diminishing any shadows bags might otherwise cause. This formula is also chock-full of anti-aging solutions, such as peptides and collagen, so it works to improve your skin while you wear it.
One buyer raved about this product for her under-eye area, writing, “I am 58 and have tried for many years to find a good concealer for dark circles caused by allergies. Most concealer either [doesn’t] cover or [looks] cakey under my eyes. I received this item first as a sample and absolutely loved it. I have since purchased a full size. It only [takes] a tiny bit to cover under-eye circles, blemishes, broken capillaries, etc.”
Where to buy: $35, Nordstrom
Yves Saint Laurent’s concealer pen has been a trade secret for more than 25 years and is a go-to for models, makeup artists, and anyone in need of an under-eye pick-me-up. Rather than simply concealing, its micro pearl flecks brighten and illuminate, so you’ll practically be radiating with well-rested, de-puffed eyes. Hyaluronic acid and vitamin E also make an appearance in the ingredient list for extra anti-aging power.
Where to buy: $21, Sephora
Fine lines can be frustrating, especially when makeup emphasizes them rather than covering them up. With this filling concealer, any “bridges” between your wrinkles will be filled in, while shadows are counteracted by skin-brightening ingredients, so your dark circles won’t stand a chance. This buildable product lasts all day, so you can put it on as thickly or thinly as you like without worrying about it. Clinique also ensures that its products are free of top allergens.
“Since I am aging and noticing more lines, I needed a concealer that masks the fine lines and wrinkles. This is PERFECT,” wrote one happy buyer. “The other products I have used in the past seem too dry, which makes the wrinkles more noticeable.”
Where to buy: $14, Sephora
When your makeup it’s gel-based, you can bet there’s a high chance it’s going to work be a primo, since it’s formulated to add hydration, plump, and reduce puffiness. Some concealers can make your skin look more texturized, which is bad news for mature skin that already has different textures from the aging process. This one, by contrast, blends seamlessly to avoid making your skin look uneven and über-bright. Hallelujah!
Where to buy: $9.29 (Originally $13.15), Amazon
Dry skin is more common as we get older, and it tends to worsen the appearance of wrinkles, so a concealer that not only camouflages, but nourishes your skin is ideal. Neutrogena’s Hydro Boost line does an impressive job of hydrating skin of all types, from sensitive to mature. Its oil-free concealer, in particular, fills in lines by injecting them with mega doses of hydration as it simultaneously conceals. What’s more, it glides on so smoothly, you won’t need to worry about it tugging on the fragile areas near your eyes.
One Amazon customer wrote: “I have been using this product for a while now, and I can safely say, this is the best, most gentle (no pull or drag on skin), moisturizing concealer I have ever used. It doesn’t accentuate fine lines, and it doesn’t look cakey. It’s almost the texture of face cream. So soft and smooth.”
Where to buy: $26, Tarte
It’s important to value the quality of ingredients that go into your body, but also the ones that are absorbed through your skin. This under-eye product stands out from the pack for its cruelty-free formula, which is also made without parabens, mineral oil, or fragrances. That means your skin will get the good end of the deal. It also lives up to its name, remaining creaseless while staying flake-free. Talk about advanced skin technology bottled up in one little tube!
Wrote one shopper, “Doesn’t make my eyes look crepey, or too light. Doesn’t settle into my lines either, seems to fill them in, making them disappear.”
Where to buy: $7.98 (Originally $9.99), Amazon
A combo of power ingredient haloxyl (an ingredient that nixes under eye circles) and antioxidant-filled goji berry found in Maybelline’s Instant Age Rewind concealer helps to brighten eyes and reduce puffiness as you wear it. While nothing can actually rewind your actual age, this formula definitely fights back against telling wrinkles and neutralizes color in the under eye area. It also lends great coverage without feeling cakey — all for less than $10!
Reviewer Sarita wrote, “It worked on my thin, but minimally-wrinkled undereye area, and on my 60-year-old mother’s more aged eye area. It’s rare that I find a product that looks great on both our skin types, and I was impressed at how well it brightened her problem skin without caking or exacerbating the age marks.”
Where to buy: $31, Sephora
If your skin has richer pigment, Lancôme is one brand that offers a decent selection of hues, and its camouflage concealer, which comes in 19 shades, is no exception. It boasts a natural, matte finish, and has a feather-light, comfortable feel.
As one Sephora reviewer commented, “Like other reviewers, I have been on a quest for the perfect concealer. I have tried numerous concealers suggested by my Sephora pros, but each time, I watched as these concealers settled into the fine lines under my eyes. It was discouraging. I tried to wear a corrector underneath these to no avail. … Until this concealer. It is unbelievable! I have given it several days and it is the most awesome concealer I have ever tried. I am 59 years old and at the end of a long day, I don’t have to reapply. It is such a nice formula.”
Where to buy: $22, Sephora
We all have those mornings where we wake up and it looks like we should probably head back to bed (hello, bags!). Benefit’s Boi-ing Hydrating Concealer will provide your under-eyes with the extra couple of hours of sleep that you’re missing. Its super creamy, hydrating formula glides on and won’t cake, even after a few layers. You won’t have to worry about reapplying throughout the day, either, since it will stay put until you get home for an actual good night’s rest.
Where to buy: $6.99, Amazon
Got puffy eyes? L’Oréal’s Visible Lift serum has you covered. Not only will it restore your natural glow with the help of sodium hyaluronate (a smaller molecule of hyaluronic acid that hydrates and penetrates the skin on a deeper level), as one reviewer discovered, it also works wonders to cease puffiness.
“I got this thinking, ‘Hey, anti-aging products usually tighten the skin, so I wonder if they would help the puffiness under my eyes?’ Well I was right,” the customer wrote. “The coverage is pretty good and it makes me look less puffy.”
Another backed her up, writing, “This does work, I’ve noticed very fine lines under my eyes plus puffiness and dark circles.”
Where to buy: $26, Tarte
This lightweight, full-coverage concealer comes straight from Tarte’s Rainforest of the Sea collection, a line that’s focused on specifically on hydrating, brightening, and defending against harmful environmental factors. What’s more, this concealer contains 20 percent water, so your skin can moisturize itself throughout the day while the product works to camouflage problem areas. Sounds like a win-win to us!
Where to buy: $4.99, Amazon
Indications of tired eyes, such as dark circles, discoloration, and puffy or uneven skin texture, can be rolled away with this powerful concealing stick. Its metal roller-ball applicator is a cool, refreshing wake-up call to your under-eyes. The addition of CC cream, meanwhile, means it doesn’t just cover, it corrects color.
“This is way more than a great cover up for dark circles,” gushed one buyer. “It really does reduce puffiness and makes my skin firmer. I am just delighted with this product. It produces a dramatic change. I really do look younger and less tired.”
Where to buy: $22, Ulta
Crepey skin, bags, and dark circles can’t compete against a swipe of this pocket-size compact. Similar to many of the other formulas on our list, this one is void of harmful ingredients, so your glow won’t come with a price. It stands out, however, for its its creamy, lightweight consistency, which is boosted with added botanical brightener to really bring out your sheen.
Where to buy: $21, Origins
Origins prides itself on its high-quality and high-performing products created with non-toxic ingredients. This specific formula is made with Anogeissus, a plant known for its antioxidants and healing effects. It also has a consistency that can nix dark under-eyes and blur wrinkles effectively without caking, creasing, or overcoating your skin.
Where to buy: $22, Sephora
Aging gracefully is much easier when you’ve got a great concealer. Thanks to a heavy slew of antioxidants, Benefit’s Boi-ing concealer goes beyond coverage to improve the texture of mature skin. The company grouped vitamin E and appleseed extract together to aid with sun protection, anti-aging, and hydration.
Wrote reviewer menomom, “If you don’t believe this can make a difference, smooth it on under one eye and compare. It took 10 years off my face. I smooth it on before my makeup and later refresh by smoothing it on over makeup. I bought both the fair and the medium. One for winter and one for summer. I will never be without it.”
Where to buy: From $5.50 (Originally $6.99), Amazon
Discovering a bright and vibrant highlighter that gets the job done without a high price tag is a pretty exciting find, and this concealing stick from Maybelline most definitely fits the bill. It’s filled with iridescent flecks that will reflect light off your face to take attention away from wrinkles and produce an “I just rolled out of bed” look you’ll look forward to. It glides on easily, but doesn’t fall or melt off quickly.
Reviewer Tara wrote, “I love this brightening stick. It has become my go-to No. 1 item to always have with me for under-eyes. As you age, you tend to lose that brightness look as we did in our teens and ’20s. This is my magic stick for under-eye brightness.”
Finding your perfect under-eye concealer match can be frustrating for those who are between tones or have hyperpigmentation. This formula by Rimmel London has the unique ability to adapt to your skin tone. A little bit of product goes along way, and the formula’s thin consistency keeps it from feeling like it’s weighing down your skin. It’s also ideal for covering age spots and under-eye circles.
Take it from this buyer, who wrote, “Color is perfect for my skin tone and I love the texture. Also the highlight part is perfect coz its like a brighter color than my skin yet it somehow matches? … It blends perfectly into my skin and is the perfect under-eye concealer!”
Where to buy: $34, Sephora
Vitamin E is blended into this formula to help condition and moisturize the skin around your eyes while simultaneously helping to cover dark circles and fine lines and correct impurities, such as blemishes.
One reviewer on Sephora wrote, “This is the best concealer I’ve ever used, especially for older women with dry skin. I will never have to look for another concealer again.”